Follow up to "young 'Hitler'" newsstory..

Discussion in 'Discussion Group' started by irishluck, Jan 14, 2009.

  1. irishluck

    irishluck Well-Known Member

  2. Hught

    Hught Well-Known Member

    I wonder why FOX took down the story, I also searched for it through other channels and it is gone.
     
  3. MisunderstoodMind

    MisunderstoodMind Well-Known Member

    Back up now:

    A 3-year-old boy named Adolf Hitler and his two Nazi-named younger sisters were removed from their New Jersey home last week and placed in state custody, police said.

    Adolf Hitler Campbell and his sisters, JoyceLynn Aryan Nation Campbell and Honszlynn Hinler Jeannie Campbell, were taken from their Holland Township, N.J., home on Friday by the state's Division of Youth and Family Services (DYFS), Sgt. John Harris of the Holland Township Police Department told FOXNews.com.

    Their father, Heath Campbell, is expected in court Thursday in Flemington, N.J., in connection with the case.

    Kate Bernyk, a spokeswoman for the DYFS, said confidentiality laws barred her from commenting on the case or even confirming that the Campbell children were involved.

    "DYFS has their reasons and they normally don’t release any information, so we kind of have to go on faith with them," Harris said. Police were not told what the agency was investigating.

    "I’ve dealt with the family for years and as far as the children are concerned, I have never had any reports of any abuse with the children," Harris said. "As far as I know, he’s always been very good with the children."

    Speaking generally, Bernyk said the state's "decision to remove a child is based on the safety and well being of the child and the risk to that child, and that decision is made in conjunction with the courts and the county family court judge."

    The Campbells made national news last month when a ShopRite supermarket refused to sell them a birthday cake with Adolf Hitler's name on it. The story generated a slew of angry Internet chatter.

    Forensic psychologist N.G. Berrill said naming a boy Hitler could be considered child abuse.

    "Part of it is the infantile nature of the parents’ behavior," Berrill said. "You can name your dog something weird, but they think they’re making some kind of bold statement with the children, not appreciating that the children will have separate lives and will be looked at in a negative light until they’re able to change their name. It is abuse."

    Last year, a New Zealand court removed a 9-year-old girl from her parents in order to change her birth name: Talula Does The Hula From Hawaii. In that country, officials do not deem a name abusive unless it causes serious bullying.

    Heath Campbell told the Easton-Express Times last year that he named his son after Adolf Hitler because he liked it and "no one else in the world would have that name."

    A paper to be published in March in Social Sciences Journal by economists David E. Kalist and Daniel Y. Lee of Shippensburg University found that unpopular first names, when mixed with factors like a disadvantaged home life, can increase the tendency toward juvenile delinquency.

    Lee told FOXNews.com that Adolf and Hitler were not names they looked at for the study.

    "Hitler most likely would be an unpopular name in the sense that not many people name their children with a name [like Hitler], but we didn’t particularly look at particularly bad names like that," he said.

    New Jersey officials said Wednesday that it is not just a matter of names.

    "DYFS would never remove a child simply based on that child's name," Bernyk said.
     
  4. peppercorns

    peppercorns Well-Known Member

    ADolph is not bad but the hitler part should go.
    And Aryan Nation - that should go too.
    Hinler? more reasons to chagne those kids names. All they are teaching them is hatred and bias.
    what ever happened to Bob and Susy are nice normal names?
     
  5. Clif001

    Clif001 Guest

    Funny, it sounds more like what they're teaching is, "A rose by any other name...".

    My 2p...

    I caught a couple minutes of a talk show yesterday where they were talking about this. The general consensus, as far as I could tell, is that, when they grow up the kids will be the target of hatred. Makes no sense, the kids didn't pick the name, the parents did.

    Just because a person has the name Hitler doesn't mean they are going to grow up to hate Jews. I mean, get real. Did John Wayne Gacy grow up to be a cowboy movie star?

    When WWII ended, everyone in Germany and Austria who had the family name of Hitler didn't suddenly change their name, nor were they required to. There are still Hitlers out there. (There might even be an "Adolph" amongst them.) We can't discriminate against everyone who happens to have the name of one of our enemies. Just ask Barack Hussein Obama.
     
  6. God'schild

    God'schild Well-Known Member

    :iagree: It is a shame that a name can bring negativity....but one must wonder at what the parents were thinking. SURELY they had enough sense to realize that those names are associated with hate, but, just did not care.
     
  7. Sherry A.

    Sherry A. Well-Known Member

    People should be able to name a child whatever but one would think that the parent(s) would realize, at least in the case we are discussing, that when the child attends school and studies history the name "Adolf Hitler" is a part genocide and every other thing this monster did.

    Maybe they home school but at some point in life these children will realize how cruel their parents were for giving them those names.

    Abuse is not only physical, sometimes mental abuse is way worse.

    For goodness sakes,
    Sherry


    Forensic psychologist N.G. Berrill said naming a boy Hitler could be considered child abuse.

    "Part of it is the infantile nature of the parents’ behavior," Berrill said. "You can name your dog something weird, but they think they’re making some kind of bold statement with the children, not appreciating that the children will have separate lives and will be looked at in a negative light until they’re able to change their name. It is abuse."

    Last year, a New Zealand court removed a 9-year-old girl from her parents in order to change her birth name: Talula Does The Hula From Hawaii. In that country, officials do not deem a name abusive unless it causes serious bullying.
     

Share This Page